MYPolygyny

Soal Jawab › Konflik & penyelesaian

🕊️ Konflik & penyelesaian · #42

My wife often contradicts and argues with me. Is that nushuz (marital defiance)?

No — differing in opinion and arguing respectfully is not nushuz; the Prophet's ﷺ own wives answered back to him.
Umar r.a. was once taken aback when his wife answered him back, and she replied that the Prophet's ﷺ wives did the same (narrated by al-Bukhari & Muslim). The Prophet ﷺ dealt with differences of opinion patiently. Nushuz is refusing to fulfil obligations without a Shariah reason, not voicing an opinion. A good husband listens, because a wife often sees what the husband does not — Ummu Salamah r.a. gave the Prophet ﷺ sound advice at Hudaibiyah. Even so, both sides must keep good manners: no insults or shouting. See Rights of husband & wife.

Sumber

Surah al-Baqarah 2:228narrated by al-Bukhari & Muslim — the account of Umar and his wifeSurah ash-Shura 42:38
← PreviousWhen should a marital conflict end in separation?Next →My spouse is addicted to drugs or gambling. What can I do?

Soalan berkaitan

I am a husband and my wife often hits and insults me. Is there help for men?Yes — domestic violence can happen to anyone, and men too are entitled to protection and help…My husband keeps threatening to divorce me every time we quarrel. What should I do?Repeated threats of divorce are a form of emotional pressure that does not befit Islamic character, and must be addressed…A wife sulks and goes back to her parents' home without permission. Is she guilty of nushuz (marital defiance)?Not necessarily — it depends on the reason and the duration; leaving out of fear, mistreatment or because no maintenance is given is not n…Should I agree to sulh (reconciliation) if my husband has abused me?You are not obliged to face or reconcile with an abuser; your safety comes first and you can ask for a procedure th…I found out my husband is cheating with another woman. What should I do?Calm yourself, confirm the facts, and get support before making big decisions. An extramarital relationship is a major sin…If a wife leaves the house out of fear of being beaten, is she guilty of nushuz?No — a wife who leaves the house to save herself from danger or abuse is not counted as guilty of nushuz. Scholars expl…
Jawapan ini rujukan umum, bukan fatwa. Untuk keadaan anda, rujuk pejabat agama, peguam syarie atau Mahkamah Syariah negeri.

Comments or feedback

Dibaca oleh pentadbir MYPolygyny dan tidak diterbitkan. Jangan sertakan maklumat peribadi yang sensitif. Notis privasi.

About Us · Ask · Site Map · Privacy · Editorial policy · Updated: 5 Oct 2026 · Disclaimer