Referee Review Form
TITLE OF MANUSCRIPT: __________________________ MANUSCRIPT ID #: _______
|
Instruction to reviewers: Please rate the manuscript on the following factors . . . |
|
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
|
|
Importance of Topic/Study for the Practice of Christian Leadership (new perspective/ approach, improvement of practice) |
Not important |
Very Important | |||||
|
Relevance of Topic/Study to the Dialogue on Transformational Servant Leadership (original, important, significant) |
Not relevant |
Relevant | |||||
|
Literature and/or Empirical Basis (adequate, relevant, situated in the field) |
Not grounded |
Highly grounded | |||||
|
Appropriateness/Rigor of Research Method (conceptually, theoretically, methodologically, and analytically sound) |
Poor design |
Strong design | |||||
|
Quality of Interpretations/ Conclusions (conclusions supported by evidence) |
Poor quality |
High quality | |||||
|
Contribution to the Literature (theoretically and/or practically significant) |
Not significant |
Highly significant | |||||
|
Overall Quality of Manuscript (writing, clarity, logic, organization) |
Poor |
Excellent | |||||
|
Figures, tables, and other supporting material (accurate, clear, necessary) |
Poor quality |
High quality |
Overall Recommendation
-
___ Outstanding manuscript, accept
-
___ Accept with minor revisions
-
___ Accept with major revisions
-
___ Inappropriate topic, refer to another journal
-
___ Reject
Please use additional pages to give confidential remarks to the editor and make comments to the author.